Facebook for Journalists: More Work Than Twitter, but With a Bigger Payout

Last week, Facebook launched a Page called Journalists on Facebook in an effort to encourage the news community to use the site’s Page feature as a distribution and research tool. Historically, Twitter has been more popular with journalists. thanks to its focus on link sharing, the additional distribution they can get thanks to the ease of retweeting, and the fact that it launched before Facebook Pages. But with Facebook sporting as many as 10 times more active users, journalists should still be focused on mastering the social network, even if takes more work than just tweeting copy and pasted URLs.

Twitter Is Quick and Simple

Twitter and Facebook offer different advantages to journalists. Twitter’s short-form nature means journalists aren’t expected to do much more than tweet the headlines and links to their articles, unless they also want to engage in discussion. Twitter’s public nature discourages low quality replies, so journalists don’t have to slog through thousands of comments the way they might on Facebook. It’s also easy to measure impact and success, even if inaccurately, by counting retweets.

Facebook on the other hand, requires journalists to craft compelling updates that stand out against the social content produced by their audience’s friends. Images, captions, and context have to be selected. Though comments to Page stories are also public, they’re not as visible as @ replies to a user’s own friends, leading large publications to receive hundreds of comments per post. While journalists want this engagement, many are too busy to actually wade through the comments and respond.

On Twitter, the line between personal and professional is easy to blur. A fledgling journalist can begin by tweeting out their articles amongst their more friendly updates, and slowly focus more on news coverage as they gain news-seeking followers outside their social circle. This transition is more difficult on Facebook. At some point, journalists have to start a Facebook Page from scratch with zero fans, or sacrifice their personal profile by turning it into a Page and converting their friends into fans using Facebook’s new profile to Page migration tool.

There’s an air of mystery to the news feed that might be discouraging journalists. With Twitter, if you tweet it, it will appear in a follower’s stream. But on Facebook, a journalist’s updates might not make it into the Top News feed, requiring users to actively sift through their Most Recent feed to find a journalist’s updates.

Twitter also had a head start, launching in July 2006 about a year before Facebook Pages, with top news outlets creating Twitter accounts in February and March of 2008. Facebook’s personal profiles have been able to publish status updates since around the time that Twitter launched  in 2006, but journalists could only accumulate up to 5,000 friends. This allowed Twitter to set the tone of shortform news distribution, while Pages have instead been framed as something that businesses and journalists have had to adapt to.

The Power of Facebook’s Rich Content Posts and Applications

Facebook Pages holds great potential for journalists, though. Pages can post rich content such as photos or videos content with previews appearing in-line. The images and captions that appear beside posted links give users just enough information that they know they want to click through. Highly interactive posts, such as those using the new Questions product, can engage users while simultaneously securing additional distribution for a journalist’s posts.

Journalists can start their own Pages, as Facebook’s new initiative encourages, but even greater power is available from using a single Page to represent an entire news organization, as Facebook has been promoting with its Facebook + Media Page since last July. Pages are designed to facilitate multiple admins, unlike Twitter accounts, and aggregating fans to a single Page helps cross-promote the work of all of a news outlet’s reporters and build a fan community.

The use of applications by journalists, something widely unexplored, could help them forge deeper bonds with users. They can collect email addresses to expand the breadth of channels through which they can content them. Many apps, designed especially for Pages, can also pull demographic and interest data, helping journalists gain insights about who their audience is. Liking a journalist’s Page creates a link back to that Page in a user’s news feed and profile, driving Likes from a fan’s network much more effectively than Twitter’s follower lists.

Larger publications willing to spend to increase their reach can use highly targeted Facebook ads to gain Likes, while Twitter’s”Promoted Tweets” doesn’t have self-serve tool, and doesn’t provide the same level of granular targeting.

While Twitter is a natural distribution channel for news, it’s not necessarily the most effective, nor does it have the widest reach. Most major publications still have more Twitter followers than Facebook fans, but that could change with time. While Facebook might require journalists to learn a new skill set and apply some effort, there is great long term value to be gained from an investment in building an audience on Facebook.

Facebook Marketing

Mediabistro Event

Facebook Marketing

Starting January 13, work with the group marketing manager of social media at Microsoft/BingAds to grow your business on Facebook! In this course, you’ll learn how to set up your company page, understand Facebook best practices, and execute a monthly content strategy. Register now!


Leave a Reply

11 Responses to “Facebook for Journalists: More Work Than Twitter, but With a Bigger Payout”

  1. The Journalist’s Guide To Dominating Facebook says:

    [...] by lawtonchiles on April 10, 2011 via insidefacebook.com [...]

  2. Drogi LOT’cie - ucz się praktyk 2.0 od kolegów! - Socjomania says:

    [...] kontaktowym” dla zdezorientowanych i szukających pomocy klientów. Komunikacja jest tam bardziej efektywna, konkretna i co najważniejsze – prawie “real-time”. Ale to nie jedyna rzecz, która świadczy o [...]

  3. Journalists & Facebook: The Future | Fit to Print says:

    [...] http://www.insidefacebook.com/2011/04/10/facebook-for-journalists-twitter/ [...]

  4. Why Twitter is Better for Journalists than Facebook - AllTwitter says:

    [...] while some might argue that Facebook offers richer content, such as polls, embedded images and the like, Twitter’s [...]

  5. InsideFacebook | Facebook for Journalists: More Work Than Twitter, but With a Bigger Payout ::clear pros/cons:: « Newsplexer says:

    [...] want this engagement, many are too busy to actually wade through the comments and respond. via insidefacebook.comImage from mashable.com GA_googleAddAttr("AdOpt", "0"); GA_googleAddAttr("Origin", "other"); [...]

  6. Facebook vs. Twitter: The Future of News Distribution « It's Not Over 'Til We Hit -30- says:

    [...] referenced an Inside Facebook post, Facebook for Journalists: More Work Than Twitter but with a Bigger Payout, earlier this week in terms of the Journalists on Facebook Page. However, the Inside Facebook post [...]

  7. Kataweb.it - Blog - SNODI di Federico Badaloni » Blog Archive » Journalists on Facebook, qualche dubbio says:

    [...] è stata lanciata la pagina “Journalists on Facebook“. A giudicare da come ne parla Inside Facebook sembra parte di una strategia di rincorsa a Twitter. Più o meno il messaggio è: se tu che sei un [...]

  8. This Week in Review: HuffPo sued over pay, early NYT pay plan results, and finding devotion on Facebook » Nieman Journalism Lab » Pushing to the Future of Journalism says:

    [...] to draw attention to its possible utility for news organizations. Josh Constine of Inside Facebook argued this week that while the journalism world seems to be particularly enamored with Twitter right now, [...]

  9. epublizisten: Facebook (nicht) nur für Journalisten says:

    [...] InsideFacebook weist auf die großen Vorteile hin, die Facebook Journalisten bieten kann. Ein Tweet reicht meist [...]

  10. My time in the Twittersphere | ashleyhasablog says:

    [...] Josh Constine says in ‘Facebook for Journalists: More Work Than Twitter, but with a Bigger Payout’, ‘Twitter’s public nature discourages low quality replies, so journalists don’t [...]

  11. Mobile Marketing Blog by QWASI » Blog Archive says:

    [...] Facebook For Journalists? [...]

Get the latest news in your inbox
interested in advertising with inside facebook?

Social Media Jobs
of the Day

Assistant Editor

8 Inc.
New York, NY

Copywriter & Editor

Santa Monica, CA

Director of Marketing & Communications

Neumans' Kitchen
New York, NY

Social Community Manager

Tallahassee, FL

Editorial Director

Phoenix House
New York, NY

Featured Company

Join leading companies like this one and recruit from the nation's top media job seekers on the Mediabistro Job Board. Every job post comes with our satisfaction guarantee. Learn More

Our Sponsors

Mediabistro A division of Prometheus Global Media home | site map | advertising/sponsorships | careers | contact us | help courses | browse jobs | freelancers | content | member benefits | reprints & permissions terms of use | privacy policy Copyright © 2014 Mediabistro Inc. call (212) 389-2000 or email us