The Current Disadvantages of Merging a Place With a Page on Facebook

With the launch of Places, Facebook began allowing businesses to merge their Page with a Place they’ve claimed. While there are some advantages for businesses focusing on generating foot traffic to a single physical location, merging has important disadvantages including lost functionality (at least for now). Here we’ll take a look two of the biggest problems with merged Places/Pages: an unfamiliar interface, and the inability to set the landing tab.

Facebook launched Places in August, allowing users to create Places for physical locations they’d like to tell their friends they’ve visited. Legitimate owners of Places can apply to claim their Place, giving them the ability to edit details, moderate comments, and advertise the Place.

The official guide to Place for advertisers explains that users who claim Places and are also an admin of a similar Page may be prompted to merge their Place and Page. Facebook recommends merging if a business has only one physical location and only one Page. The guide says, “you’ll be able to manage your business centrally on Facebook”, and Likes, content, custom tabs, and ads directing to the Page will remain intact.

However, Facebook fails to inform admins that merged Places Pages cannot be separated. This has angered some Page admins, and a few have formed a protest Page called “Unmerge Places & My Business Page“.

An important reason not to merge is that users may be confused by the change in user interface: a merged Places Page does not display tabs the way a traditional Page does. (However, it’s possible will move the tabs under the profile photo like they are on the recently redesigned user profiles – though Facebook hasn’t said that.) Instead, it uses a navigation panel beneath the Page’s picture. Users won’t see a panel of friends who Like that Places Page or previews of uploaded photos and videos, plus the option to suggest the Places Page to friends is dropped to the very bottom of the left sidebar.

Engaging with merged Places Pages is more difficult as well. The default landing tab is the Profile, which shows the Places address, a map, hours, and a description. Even if users have Liked the Places Page, they still see this tab upon visiting, and have to navigate to the Wall via the navigation panel in order to share their opinions or publish content. This is much different than traditional Pages, where those who’ve clicked Like can immediately post to the wall upon visiting. If getting users to communicate with each other and foster a sense of community is a business’ goal, the traditional Page is a better fit because those who’ve clicked Like see the Wall and publisher first.

While this navigation format is similar to the newly redesigned user profile, users are accustomed to seeing tab applications along the top of a Page, not running down the left sidebar.

Another serious deficiency of merged Places Pages is that admins cannot change the landing tab. Many businesses spend a lot of money or time creating custom tab applications or outsourcing this job to a Page management company. Being unable to show these apps to those who haven’t Liked your merged Places Page can hurt Page growth. Therefore, merged Places Pages miss out on much of the opportunity to condition access to tab app contests or content on a user Liking the Page.

It’s possible that Facebook will address these issues in upcoming product updates, but that’s the way it works for now.

Facebook says a “A solution for linking multiple Places to a single Facebook Page will become available in the future”, but it first needs to make this a more attractive option. The ability to set a landing tab promotes Page growth, which is important to Facebook as well as admins.

Social Media 101

Mediabistro Course

Social Media 101

Get hands-on social media training for beginners in our online boot camp, Social Media 101! Starting September 4, social media and marketing experts will teach you the best practices to be successful on social. Register before July 31 to get $50 OFF with early bird pricing. Register now!

 

Leave a Reply

10 Responses to “The Current Disadvantages of Merging a Place With a Page on Facebook”

  1. Bastian says:

    Very useful information. They certainly fail important details to inform the page administrators. One should be able to test the waters first.

    It looks like tabs are being erased from existance (ok, hidden), but there are tons of money invested in tab-apps.

    I believe this will affect business and will have a negative impact on Facebook itself. Lets hope they will change their way of doing ‘upgrades’ to their interface.

  2. MattS says:

    Thank you for this write up! I just got off the phone with a customer asking me if they should merge their place page and fan page. I havent had a chance to dig into any draw backs of doing this and now I can see a few. I’m guessing some of these will be addressed by FB since this is a relatively new service.

  3. Nicky Jurd says:

    Thanks for the article Josh, I’ve been wondering about this exactly!

    We are also experiencing delays claiming our Place Page, and I’m still waiting on ‘an email’ from Facebook.

    It would be awesome if Facebook could update its help pages with more info.

  4. Friday Fodder | NST Blog – News and Smart Talk for Nuffer, Smith, Tucker Inc. says:

    [...] With the launch of Places, Facebook began allowing businesses to merge their Page with a Place they’ve claimed. While there are some advantages for businesses focusing on generating foot traffic to a single physical location, merging has important disadvantages including lost functionality (at least for now). http://bit.ly/evygtK [...]

  5. Tech Tip Tuesday Dec 21 | BlogAid says:

    [...] your existing Facebook page with Places, you’ll want to read this post from Inside Facebook on The Current Disadvantages of Merging a Place with a Page on Facebook [...]

  6. Kim says:

    I just wanted to note that you CAN unmerge…..at least it looks like you can. I just merged our places and page and at the very bottom of the left column there’s this: Unmerge all merged Places

    Click it and you get this: Are you sure you want to unmerge all claimed Places from this Page?Learn more
    Once you confirm this request, the format of this Page will be reverted to the previous format and location information will be removed. The Places that you merged will be restored as separate claimed Places that you also still own and must continue to manage.
    Facebook is constantly exploring ways to enhance our Places and Pages products. We will notify you about possible changes and enhancements to these products in the future.

  7. Oneupweb : Facebook Page Admins Can Now Unmerge Places and Pages | Oneupweb : StraightUpSocial Blog says:

    [...] your Place with your Page presented some major obstacles. The one that stood out to me was the inability to set a landing tab. As I’ve previously [...]

  8. To Merge or Not: Facebook Page with Facebook Places | Gourmet Marketing News says:

    [...] The Current Disadvantages of Merging a Place With a Page on Facebook (insidefacebook.com) [...]

  9. Kerry Wilson says:

    If you merge your Places page to your FanPage that has a URL Username, will you keep your URL Username from your FanPage?

  10. To Merge or Not: Facebook Page with Facebook Places | Gourmet Marketing says:

    [...] The Current Disadvantages of Merging a Place With a Page on Facebook (insidefacebook.com) [...]

Get the latest news in your inbox
interested in advertising with inside facebook?

Social Media Jobs
of the Day

Opportunities in Digital Publishing

Pew Research Center
Washington, DC

Vice President of Technology

Emerald Media Group
Eugene, OR

Social Media Strategist

ISACA
Rolling Meadows, IL

Social Media Specialist

California Academy of Sciences
San Francisco, CA

Featured Company

Join leading companies like this one and recruit from the nation's top media job seekers on the Mediabistro Job Board. Every job post comes with our satisfaction guarantee. Learn More
 

Our Sponsors

Also from Inside Network:   AppData - Facebook & iOS Application Stats   PageData - Engagement Data on Facebook Pages   Facebook Marketing Bible   Inside Network Research
 
home | site map | advertising/sponsorships | about | careers | contact us | help courses | browse jobs | freelancers | events | forums | content | member benefits | reprints & permissions terms of use | privacy policy Copyright © 2014 Mediabistro Inc. call (212) 389-2000 or email us