Special Purpose Investment Vehicles Snap Up Facebook Shares

A new type of player is emerging in the market for Facebook shares.

Investors are banding together and creating a growing number of entities that exist solely to buy stock in the company. While investors have been able to purchase shares from former employees for the past few years, these funds underscore ballooning interest in Facebook after it surpassed 500 million users this year. It also has shown off increasingly established revenue streams, including brand and performance advertising, and its virtual currency, Credits.

In the private market for Facebook stock, sellers typically want to offload several hundred thousand dollars to more than $1 million in Facebook shares at a time. So smaller investors will join together, pooling amounts of between $25,000 to a few hundred thousand dollars in order to buy them.

“A manager will put together a limited liability corporation, look for a large block of shares, then raise the money to purchase them from smaller investors who wouldn’t meet the individual trade size,” said Greg Brogger, the chief executive of SharesPost, a site where buyers and sellers can list public offers for the stock. “The LLC will aggregate the investment and write a single check.”

Dubbed special purpose vehicles or issuer-specific funds, they are usually formed by private wealth management groups, institutional investors, investment banks or people who are already well-connected to the company’s leadership.

These entities are counted as single shareholders, so they help Facebook skirt the the sensitive 500 shareholder limit at which the Securities and Exchange Commission begins requiring companies to make more extensive financial disclosures, according to Mark Murphy, who heads public affairs at SecondMarket, a New York-based online marketplace for alternative assets.

Boaz Rahav, a general partner at newly formed GreenCrest Capital, is putting together a fund to buy $100 million in Facebook shares on behalf of institutional investors. He says the firm has cultivated relationships with a number of former Facebook employees based on the West Coast that want to sell part of their holdings.

“There is a large group of senior former Facebook employees — some of whom are relatively young — that are sitting on warrants or shares that appreciated ten or twenty-fold over the last 18-24 months,” he said. “We have a unique access point to large blocks of shares.”

The minimum investment is $250,000. Then, Greencrest charges an initial 5 percent entrance fee, and a 20 percent carry on the profits if investors have a return of greater than 20 percent. He wouldn’t specify the price Greencrest is buying the shares at, except to say that it’s a range the firm has been monitoring daily. Rahav says the firm doesn’t have special access to Facebook’s financial statements so investors need to do their own due diligence.

In a prospectus for another $40 million Facebook-specific fund that we saw, investors were asked to put down at least $100,000 each.

Special-purpose vehicles for Facebook shares started to appear in 2008, according to Adam Oliveri, who heads private company markets at SecondMarket. But they’ve grown in prominence over the past year as investor demand for the social network’s shares have driven its implied valuation to around $56.7 billion, according to the most recently completed trade on SharesPost. (Keep in mind that beyond Facebook’s success, scarcity is also driving up the valuation. There are few eligible sellers because current Facebook employees are banned from selling their holdings, and because most of Facebook’s newer employees have restricted stock units or RSUs, which are non-transferrable.)

The new issuer-specific funds are still outnumbered by hedge funds with broader portfolios by 10 to 1, Oliveri said. But they indicate intense interest in a company that may come forward for an initial public offering in a few years.

“When we first started trading Facebook stock, it took us about two months to find an appropriate buyer and negotiate the transaction, price, and get an appropriate purchase and sale agreement,” Oliveri said. “Today, that entire process takes two hours.”

Rahav said he believes Facebook would be accepting of firms like Greencrest since they help the company avoid pushing the number of shareholders close to the SEC limits.

“We’re many sellers under one roof,” he said. “We think that Facebook will welcome players like us that have an institutional modus operandi and aggregate the buyers for them.” Both Facebook and the company’s legal counsel at Fenwick & West declined to comment.

Because of these sensitive limits, Facebook has employees who, among other duties, are responsible for monitoring the secondary market. It also has helped early employees sell shares and diversify their holdings by facilitating special transactions with Russian investment firm Digital Sky Technologies. DST was favored, in part, because it was already an existing shareholder.

“Facebook has become a great deal more hands-on with the secondary market,” Oliveri said. “They certain require certain purchase and sale agreements and they’ve updated their company governing documents and bylaws to take the secondary market into account.”

Those changes include forbidding non-original shareholders from reselling their holdings without the company’s approval and requiring a $2,500 fee to cover administrative costs of a sale.

This Week’s Headlines on Inside Social Games

ISG LogoCheck out the top headlines and insights this week from Inside Social Games – tracking all the latest developments at the intersection of games and social platforms.

Monday, October 25th, 2010

Tuesday, October 26th, 2010

Wednesday, October 27th, 2010

Thursday, October 28th, 2010

Friday, October 29th, 2010

Highlights This Week from the Inside Network Job Board: Storm8, EA & More

Recently, we launched the Inside Network Job Board – dedicated to providing you with the best job opportunities in the Facebook Platform and social gaming ecosystem.

Here are this week’s highlights from the Inside Network Job Board, including positions at Storm8EAPosit SciencePlayfish,  and MetroGames.

Listings on the Inside Network Job Board are distributed to readers of Inside Facebook and Inside Social Games through regular posts and widgets on the sites. That way, you can be sure that your open positions are being seen by the leading developers, product managers, marketers, designers, and executives in the Facebook Platform and social gaming industry today.

Facebook Roundup: Murphy, Facebook Phone, Bit.ly, Groups, Lobbying, Places and Breakups

Facebook’s Murphy Leaves Company – Mike Murphy, Facebook’s vice president of global sales and a long-time employee, is leaving the company to focus on his family at the end of this quarter. There are no immediate plans to replace him. [Image via Facebook]

More on Facebook Phone – We wrote about the purported “Facebook phone” last month, but more details were reported this week. The projects may be aimed entirely at creating a social mobile phone platform, along the lines of previous reports, and is being run by vice president of  growth Chamath Palihapitiya in a separate building near the company’s Palo Alto, Calif. headquarters.

Facebook Plans New Groups Icons – Facebook designer Soleio Cuervo responded to a query on Quora about Groups icons and said in reference to broken heart icons, “We’ll be offering more groups icons after my return from vacation. Some of the recycled icons that were previously scrapped will replace their former selves in meaning and representation.”

Facebook, Bit.ly ‘Frenemies’ – TechCrunch reports that Facebook seems to be both working against bit.ly — creating its own fb.me URL shortener — and with bit.ly by shortening some links with the service. More at the link.

Facebook Lobbies Against Privacy Laws – Facebook spent more than $6,600 lobbying California officials against passing the Social Networking Privacy Act. We wrote about Facebook hiring its first California lobbyist earlier this year. More information here.

Facebook Apps InfluentialA recent study found that Facebook applications are either extremely influential or not influential at all — there’s no in-between. More at the link.

Facebook Releases ‘It Gets Better’ Video – Facebook employees participated in a video for the It Gets Better Project, which aims to encourage gay adolescents not to harm themselves over bullying.

Breakup Data on Facebook – Apparently, people like to break up before Spring Break, on Mondays, at the beginning of the summer and before Christmas, this according to a recent analysis of when people announce breakups on Facebook.

Facebook Nook Integration – Facebook has collaborated with Barnes & Noble to release a NookColor Facebook integration allowing users to recommend books to friends, share a reading status, share quotes and lend an e-book to a friend.

Facebook Joins Alliance to Save Energy – Facebook joined the Alliance to Save Energy and plans to have a new Green Page to promote energy efficiency.

Facebook Sues Over Faceporn Name – Facebook is suing Faceporn.com, an adult social networking site, over its name alleging violation of copyright.

WPP, Buddy Media Announce Partnership – Communication services group WPP and Buddy Media announced a partnership to help global brands scale their Facebook marketing efforts. WPP will invest $5 million into Buddy Media, more at the link.

Singer Launches Places Marketing – British singer Cheryl Cole has launched a new billboard campaign urging fans to see her on Facebook and Places. She’s promoting a new album and tour and fans on Facebook have the chance to win tickets.

BitDefender Protects Facebook Users – BitDefender is a Facebook app designed to protect Facebook users from spam, privacy invasion and other threats. It checks your information for “fishy” items and offers you the option of deleting them.

Facebook Updates User ID Policy, Puts Six Month Block on Rogue Application Developers

Following an arguably overblown investigation into Facebook application developers sharing publicly-available user identification numbers with third parties, Facebook has made a few additional moves to clamp down on the problem. One is a policy update, another is punishment for those developers that purposefully sold this information — most had done it accidentally — and a third is confirmation of a change it previously proposed to how user IDs are handled.

Given that the user IDs are already publicly available, there was no privacy violation — contrary to how many news organizations covered the story. But selling user data to third parties is explicitly forbidden in Facebook’s developer terms. So Facebook’s actions here are likely motivated in part by the need to reassure the public that their (public) data is safe, while also setting an example to developers.

First, the policy change, from the company’s developer blog post on the matter:

Today, we are clarifying our policy to ensure that developers understand the proper use of UIDs in their applications. Our policy has always stated that data received from Facebook, including UIDs, cannot be shared with data brokers and ad networks. Moving forward, our policy will state that UIDs cannot leave your application or any of the infrastructure, code, and services you need to build and run your application. You can use services, such as Akamai, Amazon Web Services and analytics services as long as those services keep UIDs confidential to your application.

Second, developers will also need to adopt the new mechanism for making user IDs anonymous.

We realize that developers may sometimes need a way to share a unique identifier outside of their application with permitted third parties, such as content partners, advertisers or other service providers. We are adding a mechanism that developers must use to share anonymous identifiers for this purpose. We will release this functionality (available via the Graph API and FQL) early next week. We encourage developers to move to this mechanism quickly and will require it on January 1, 2011.

Ad networks on Facebook, the post notes, are also being required to delete any IDs in their possession in order to continue doing business on the platform; Facebook is also requiring that developers anonymize any IDs they send to these companies.

It is also banning some currently unknown developers for having purposefully brokered this data to third parties. It’s not naming names, but please let us know in comments if you have more information about who they are. From the post:

As we examined the circumstances of inadvertent UID transfers, we discovered some instances where a data broker was paying developers for UIDs. While we determined that no private user data was sold and confirmed that transfer of these UIDs did not give access to any private data, this violation of our policy is something we take seriously. As such, we are taking action against these developers by instituting a 6-month full moratorium on their access to Facebook communication channels, and we will require these developers to submit their data practices to an audit in the future to confirm that they are in compliance with our policies. This impacts fewer than a dozen, mostly small developers, none of which are in the top 10 applications on Facebook Platform.

Finally, Facebook says it has worked out a deal where one of the data brokers that was buying the data, Rapleaf, will delete all user IDs in its possession

Facebook Acquires Drop.io, Founder Lessin Joins the Company

Facebook acquired drop.io, a private sharing service founded by Sam Lessin, a longtime friend of chief executive Mark Zuckerberg, the New York-based startup said today. The acquisition price was not disclosed.

Lessin is the only employee from the company who will join Facebook and Drop.io said it would wind down its service. The company had raised close to $4 million from RRE Ventures, DFJ Gotham Ventures and Rose Tech Ventures.

Facebook said in a statement, “We can confirm that we recently completed a small talent acquisition for drop.io and acquired most of the company’s assets. We’re thrilled that Sam Lessin will be joining us.”

It is difficult to predict what Lessin will be working on since many of the entrepreneurs Facebook has attracted through acquisitions have ended up working on projects unrelated to their original startup ideas.

However, Facebook has been moving in a direction recently that promotes more private sharing. It launched Groups earlier this fall, which are enclosed spaces where small groups of friends can share content with each other.

Lessin and Zuckerberg go far back to their days at Harvard University. In David Kirkpatrick’s book, “The Facebook Effect,” Lessin praised Facebook for its minimalism. His father also took Zuckerberg around New York to meet venture capitalists and media and finance executives, Kirkpatrick reported.

Drop.io is the Facebook’s eighth acquisition to date and the sixth one in the last year. (Another reported acquisition, Chai Labs, was never officially confirmed.) Many acquired founders have gone on to assume high-profile roles in the company. Friendfeed co-founder Bret Taylor became chief technology officer. Parakey co-founder Blake Ross worked on Facebook Lite and Questions, while his co-founder Joe Hewitt led development of Facebook’s iPhone application. NextStop co-founder Carl Sjogreen is now leading platform while Justin Shaffer, who founded location service Hot Potato, leads Groups.

Drop.io disclosed the acquisition on its blog today:

Here at drop.io, we’ve had a great three years helping people privately share pictures, video, audio, documents, andmore. It’s been a thrill to watch the first, thousandth, millionth, and ten-millionth drop be created.

Today, we’re proud to announce that we’ve struck a deal with Facebook. What this means is that Facebook has bought most of drop.io’s technology and assets, and Sam Lessin is moving to Facebook.

In the coming weeks, we’ll be winding down the drop.io service. As of this week, people will no longer be able to create new free drops, but you’ll be able to download content from existing drops until Dec. 15. Paid user accounts will still be available through Dec. 15 and paid users will be able to continue using the service normally. After Dec. 15, paid accounts will be discontinued as well.

Please download your information before Dec. 15 – we plan to delete it after that time. No user data or content will be transferred to Facebook, and we’ll send out e-mails to everyone to remind them about the service closing.

Other drop.io services like Presslift, our Yahoo! Mail Application, and our APIs will stay online for a longer period before the company winds down. We’ll announce more details on that soon. However, starting immediately, we’ll no longer be selling new premium accounts for those services.

To our loyal users and fans, we cannotthank you enough for your patronage, support, and feedback (good and bad) over the years.

Warmest regards, The drop.io Team

A Look at Halloween-Themed Apps and Pages on Facebook

Halloween is a retail blitz that comes and goes pretty quickly between the back-to-school and holiday shopping seasons. But nonetheless, the spooky holiday has made an appearance on Facebook as far as big brands, small businesses and regular folks go.

One big brand that took advantage of Halloween was Converse, with its Frankenpic application. The app has been the landing Page on the Converse Page, which made our Top 20 Pages list this week, and according to our AppData service, has 313,900 monthly active users and 23,400 daily active users.

Basically, a Facebook user can either take a web cam photo (no profile picture uploads or built-in camera photos unfortunately) and then combine that with a variety of body parts to make what amounts to a photo illustration of themselves. The three parts available for mixing include the head, the chest/arms and the legs. By Liking the Page users gain access to more effects for this illustration, and once it’s complete, you can Share or publish to your Wall.

Halloween applications also appeared in Spanish and Italian, apparently aimed at users outside of countries where the day has traditionally been celebrated.

The Spanish language app Tu Disfraz Ideal (Your Ideal Costume) basically generates a costume for you, if you don’t like it, you can change it. You may then publish this to your stream; the app has 1 million monthly active users according to the Facebook Page. The app also works for your friends, you can choose a cheesy costume and publish it to their Wall.

The Spirit Halloween store’s Facebook Page has been giving away daily prizes by inciting users to Like the Page but didn’t really have a huge integration other than that.

A variety of other businesses seized upon the Halloween holiday to do their own versions of Facebook marketing. Iams, a pet food company, asked its fans to post their favorite Halloween moment with their pets to the Wall and for every photo the company would donate 131 meals to pet shelters.

Many small businesses encouraged people to post Halloween photos to their Pages or posted their own staff’s, like Bozeman Deaconess Hospital in Bozeman, Montana did. Meanwhile, Book Hoodies asked its fans to post photos of children or grandchildren, ask friends to Like the photos, in order to win merchandise: book covers. Still, other groups used Facebook to market Halloween-related events, like Rinehart Realty in Rock Hill, South Carolina’s costume party, Equality Texas’ promotion of its costume party or the Halloween launch party event created by The Sugarmill in Hanley, UK.

In essence, many people and organizations took advantage of Facebook’s viral features to spread the word about their Halloween activities this year. For more information on how to do the same for your business check out the Inside Facebook Marketing Bible.

And let us know if your company or organization has an interesting Halloween integration by emailing scalderon (at) insidenetwork (dot) com.

Mixi Profile Link Lets Users Syndicate Facebook Content to the Japanese Social Network

Facebook has released a version of its Profile Link product which allows users to syndicate their content to the Japanese social network Mixi. This follows up on the recent release of the product for Google’s Orkut, and we expect more similar integrations to roll out as well.

Users can syndicate Facebook status updates, Notes and more with their Mixi friends. The product was built using the public Mixi Graph API, and does not necessarily constitute a partnership between the social networks.

Japan has become a major target for growth this year, with Facebook sending some top engineers there to develop a version of the site that better fits the country’s culture where many users access social networking sites through feature phones and touch interfaces which don’t recognize cookies. Facebook recently began allowing Japanese mobile users to log in to Facebook via QR codes.

A major obstacle to growth has been the entrenched popularity of Mixi, which has 20 million users. This dwarfs Facebook’s current 1,426,480 users, or just 1.1% of the Japanese population, according to the The Facebook Global Monitor, part of Inside Facebook Gold, our membership service tracking Facebook’s business and growth around the world. Widespread virality is difficult in Japan because the average social network user there only has 29 friends, compared to the worldwide Facebook average of 130. This means Japanese users are less likely to send Facebook invites to those who are not in their immediate social circle.

In an effort that may be designed to lure Mixi users to Facebook, the Mixi Profile Link not only syndicates Facebook content, but also pulls the user’s Mixi friend list through the Mixi API. Upon clicking the “Link your Profile with Mixi” button, users are brought to a Mixi permissions page where they authorize Facebook to pull this and other data. Facebook might use this data to help users find their Mixi friends on Facebook, reducing their need to use the Japanese site.

If it wants to grow there, Facebook will need to find a way to improve on Mixi by facilitating the uniquely private way social networks are used in Japan. Offering selective sharing through the new Groups product could be part of the answer, but the way in which users are forcibly added and not invited to join Groups by their friends might not match Japanese social norms. As the deployed engineering team designs the Facebook Japan interface, we’ll be here covering their efforts.

Update: We’ve learned that users can only syndicate Facebook content to Mixi if that content that has the privacy setting of “Everyone”. This prevents users from sharing to only a limited set of Facebook and Mixi friends, and clashes with the more private nature of Mixi users.

To enable sharing to Mixi for those with more restrictive settings, Facebook provides a button which changes their “Posts by Me” privacy setting to “Everyone”.

[Thanks to Bill Perrin for the privacy control screenshot]

Facebook Provides Page Updates to Search Engine Yandex in Exchange for Exposure in Russia

Facebook has partnered with Yandex, Russia’s largest search engine, to index updates to Pages and show users of the search engine their Facebook notifications. The integration is not live yet, but will augment Yandex’s existing index of twitter.com, livejournal.com and Russian blog platform liveinternet.ru.

Yandex will show different Facebook content in search results than Microsoft’s Bing, which joined the Instant Personalization program this month. Bing shows Likes on search results, while Yandex will include Page updates in a similar fashion to search engines including Booshaka and Open Facebook Search. Facebook will also display a widget on the Yandex front page, providing constant exposure for the social network.

Facebook recently increased its focus on the Russian market, signing deals with Russian mobile carriers to offer free access to Facebook. Despite having to compete with local social networks such as Vkontake and Odnoklassniki, Facebook is now growing relatively quickly there. According to The Facebook Global Monitor, part of our Inside Facebook Gold membership service, Facebook increased it’s Russian audience by 16.8%, or 228,960 users in September 2010. Still, Facebook has only registered 1.1% of the Russian population, so the Yandex partnership presents a new way of gaining exposure to Russia’s 60 million internet users.

Instead of crawling Facebook to index social content, Yandex will receive a syndication feed of Page updates directly from Facebook. This reduces the lag between content being posted and being indexed. The press release also mentions personal search, but doesn’t explain whether Yandex will show Facebook user profiles or Page profiles as results to searches for names.

Javier Olivan, Facebook’s Head of International, says “this partnership will bring a lot of value for our Russian users”. The partnership will get the Facebook name and content in front of millions of Russians. This may help Facebook to accelerate growth in the area in exchange for giving Yandex faster access to data which is already public.


My Kingdom Rises, Falls on This Week’s List of Emerging Facebook Apps

Two apps on this week’s AppData list of emerging Facebook games pulled in over 800,000 new monthly active users — an impressive feat, since our emerging game cutoff is a total of a million MAU. Both My Kingdom and Social Fun are new to Facebook, and growing fast.

Top Gainers This Week
Name MAU Gain Gain,%
1. App_2_152645868106521_5766 My Kingdom 915,581 +856,326 +1,445%
2. App_2_181606049889_436 Social Fun 945,509 +817,094 +636%
3. App_2_145576808817954_7968 dtac one D.I.Y. 971,394 +496,808 +105%
4. Original لعبة الحقيقة 612,303 +478,218 +357%
5. App_2_157531047591855_5508 Sim Hospital 595,054 +393,580 +195%
6. Original My Photos 676,726 +379,297 +128%
7. App_2_157785064239480_3718 恐龍王國 438,813 +359,220 +451%
8. App_2_146340918729491_2110 BRAAAINS 878,769 +295,992 +51%
9. App_2_141437422542260_5503 CSI: Crime City 307,357 +275,074 +852%
10. App_2_120065608052360_3390 ๑۩۞۩๑ HAPPY HALLOWEEN ! ๑۩۞۩๑ 312,037 +255,628 +453%
11. App_2_107686462622879_9313 the button 631,661 +254,035 +67%
12. App_2_115478888511670_1708 Card Rivals 235,719 +231,863 +6,013%
13. App_2_124906320895632_5894 Most Mutual Friends 638,260 +213,757 +50%
14. App_2_119866281385524_978 Wheel Of Fortune 887,864 +209,449 +31%
15. Original Your statistics 771,693 +209,237 +37%
16. Original Pumpkin Solitaire 309,744 +204,959 +196%
17. Original mypatente 248,349 +204,482 +466%
18. Original Photobucket 969,961 +199,642 +26%
19. App_2_115772018460159_5377 How old do you look? 924,357 +198,878 +27%
20. App_2_109462332444375_8846 Roman Taxi 421,272 +191,518 +83%

Unfortunately, My Kingdom may not survive its success. Although the app was operative on Thursday, it now redirects to Facebook’s home page, which suggests that the new Happy Elements title may have been suspended.

Social Fun has a vague name, but the Spanish-language quiz app is not particularly unusual. It’s followed by dtac one D.I.Y., an app by a Thai mobile carrier that allows users to create their own avatar. And rounding out the foreign-language apps at the top, لعبة الحقيقة is another standard offering, a friend quiz for the Arabic-speaking audience.

At number five, Sim Hospital the top-ranking game on this week’s list; it puts players in control of a fledgling hospital, with extra points earned for correct diagnoses. We’re covering the other games this morning at Inside Social Games.

Skipping down, ๑۩۞۩๑ HAPPY HALLOWEEN ! ๑۩۞۩๑ is the first themed app for the holiday we’ve seen do well this season — perhaps a sign that such apps aren’t as popular as they once were. We’ll find out whether that’s really true as the holiday season starts.

Inside Facebook Sponsors
LifeStreet AvenueSocial Qwaya Forrester report! Nanigans Frima Shoutlet Softlayer
Featured Company
Jobs of the Day

SOCIALDEALER
Oakbrook Terrace, IL

Mullen
Pittsburgh, PA

Carnegie Endowment for International Peace
Washington, DC

More Research & Information from Inside Facebook

Sign up for free email updates beyond today's news.

 

Also from Inside Network:   AppData - Facebook & iOS Application Stats   PageData - Engagement Data on Facebook Pages   Facebook Marketing Bible   Inside Virtual Goods
WebMediaBrands
Mediabistro | SemanticWeb | Inside Network
Jobs | Education | Research | Events | News
Advertise | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy
Copyright 2012 WebMediaBrands Inc. All rights reserved.