Facebook Settles Beacon Case: No More Beacon, But There’s a $9.5M “Privacy Fund”

Facebook tried to create a new form of advertising in 2007 with the launch of Beacon. In conjunction with a number of big-name brands, Beacon automatically tracked Facebook users’ actions on other sites, then displayed that information to their friends back on Facebook. The program is now officially dead.

A class-action lawsuit filed in 2008 has been settled today. There are two parts. One is that Beacon, as it has been, will be fully shut down — only a few accounts are still open and those will be closed. The other part is that Facebook will, from our understanding, fund an independent foundation to the tune of $9.5 million. The foundation will itself fund projects and initiatives that promote privacy, safety, and security causes.

The case was settled, not lost by Facebook. Here’s what a company spokesperson told me when I asked for more detail:

While we don’t admit any wrongdoing in this matter, we did want to get the episode behind us. And, we were particularly interested in an agreement that creates a foundation that has value for all users rather than just a few individuals.

The settlement has not yet been approved by the judge, and the case was just filed. It took place in the Northern District of California part of the US District Court, San Jose Division. We’ll update with a link to the settlement when it becomes available.

The original filing described some elements of Beacon that were particularly troublesome to the plaintiffs, per the original lawsuit. From that filing, via Justia:

Plaintiffs alleged that Defendant Facebook, Inc. and Defendants Facebook Beacon Activated Affiliates (i.e., Blockbuster, Inc., Fandango, Inc., Hotwire, Inc., STA Travel, Inc., Overstock.com, Inc., Zappos.com, Inc. and Gamefly, Inc.) violated their privacy.

More on the original lawsuit, via CNET:

If the user was not a member (of Facebook), Facebook still obtained the notification from the Facebook Beacon Activated Affiliate. Information regarding user activities was sent in real time to a third party Web site–one which was not open or active in the user’s browser, and one which, in many cases, the user may never even have visited or heard of.

Facebook’s side of the story is that the company made a number of adjustments to Beacon in the weeks and months following the launch that met many user demands. This case was filed long after much of the outcry about Beacon had ebbed.

Future plans

I asked about the impact of this ruling on Facebook’s current efforts to share data with third-parties, including Facebook Connect. Here was the response.

Beacon was about our users’ actions on third-party sites. Facebook Connect is about using Facebook infrastructure to give users significant control over how they extend their Facebook identity on the web, and share their experience back to friends on Facebook

More statements, these from Barry Schnitt, Facebook’s Director of Policy Communications.

We learned a great deal from the Beacon experience. For one, it was underscored how critical it is to provide extensive user control over how information is shared. We also learned how to effectively communicate changes that we make to the user experience. The introduction of Facebook Connect – a product that gives users significant control over how they extend their Facebook identity on the Web and share experiences back to friends on Facebook – is an example of this. We look forward to the creation of the foundation and its work to educate Internet users on how best to control their privacy; engage in safe social networking practices; and, generally, enjoy themselves more online by having knowledge that gives them a greater sense of control. We fully expect the foundation to team with other leading online safety and privacy experts and organizations that have been working diligently in these fields.

Social Media 101

Mediabistro Course

Social Media 101

Get hands-on social media training for beginners in our online boot camp, Social Media 101! Starting September 4, social media and marketing experts will teach you the best practices to be successful on social. Register now!

 

Leave a Reply

8 Responses to “Facebook Settles Beacon Case: No More Beacon, But There’s a $9.5M “Privacy Fund””

  1. Facebook Settles Beacon Case: No More Beacon, But There’s a $9.5M “Privacy Fund” [ Inside Facebook ] says:

    [...] Facebook Settles Beacon Case: No More Beacon, But There’s a $9.5M “Privacy Fund” Found 35 minutes, 30 seconds ago Facebook tried to create a new form of advertising in 2007 with the launch of Beacon. In conjunction with a number of big-name brands, Beacon automatically tracked Facebook users action’s on other sites, then displayed that information to their friends back on Facebook. The program is now officially dead. A class-action lawsuit filed in 2008 has [...] From: http://www.insidefacebook.com [...]

  2. Rado Stoyanov says:

    Very strong move.

    Perhaps they realized that a huge chunk of monetization will go with an almost exact approach and stream. Facebook Connect established the channel and now the flow will commence, only this time in the other direction.

    Furthermore this foundation, if run well, may boost the next step in usability. Through education and guidance. As always. :)

  3. Jay Cuthrell says:

    When I consider the use of Facebook notification emails that are sent from the address “noreply” by Facebook I’m curious where Barry’s concern over

    “how critical it is to provide extensive user control over how information is shared”

    will evolve if/when Facebook ever gets around to allowing actual replies to notifications in the same manner as FriendFeed does now that they are a whole company.

    I asked this question at TC50 and they dodged it. A second person followed up with a similar question and they dodged it again.

    So, knowing there is this “privacy fund”, I wonder how much of that fund will be devoted to addressing any deviation from the noreply methods used today for email communication outside of the Facebook silo.

  4. Eric Eldon says:

    Agreed, Rado.

    Jay, I’d personally like to see the email-reply feature, too. It strikes me as the sort of thing they’ll have one day, but we shall see.

  5. forest says:

    Facebook needed a kick in the butt. It’s always been a fairly invasive program and this was a good boot!

  6. facebookmarketing.de | Vanity Login, Beacon tot, Watir, Vertrauen in Facebook (Kurzmitteilungen 13) says:

    [...] in Deutschland nicht sonderlich bekannte oder verbreitete Funktion, das Facebook Beacon wurde nun nach einem Rechtsstreit deaktiviert. Beacons erlaubten es Aktivitäten von Facebook Nutzern auf anderen Webseiten auch ohne deren [...]

  7. The Demise of Facebook’s Beacon, and Lessons Learned « The Social Scene says:

    [...] The Demise of Facebook’s Beacon, and Lessons Learned 6 10 2009 Facebook has reached a settlement in the class-action lawsuit over it’s ill-fated advertising platform, Beacon.  Launched in 2007, Beacon tracked user activity on third-party affiliate sites and posted the resulting data on the user’s Facebook profile page.  This attempt to generate word-of-mouth buzz by broadcasting the consumer habits of users became an instant controversy, sparking concerns over privacy, transparency, and the inadequacy of user controls.  A Computer Associates report amplified these concerns, alleging that the Beacon program collected data from third-party sites for users who aren’t even Facebook members.   In the wake of the controversy, affiliate partners quickly abandoned the program, and some became ensnared in legal battles of their own.  With yesterday’s proposed settlement, the Beacon program is now officially dead.  [...]

  8. Facebook’s Conflict of Interest in Privacy says:

    [...] Facebook Settles Beacon Case: No More Beacon, But There’s a $9.5M “Privacy Fund” (insidefacebook.com) [...]

Get the latest news in your inbox
interested in advertising with inside facebook?

Social Media Jobs
of the Day

In-house Graphic/Web Designer

KOAMTAC, Inc.
Princeton, NJ

Creative Director for Web Design

3D Systems
Rock Hill, SC

Web & Graphic Assistant

Callahan & Associates
Washington, DC

Junior Web Engineer

MakerBot Industries
Brooklyn, NY

Web Editor, Eat This Not That

Eat This Not That
New York, NY

Featured Company

Join leading companies like this one and recruit from the nation's top media job seekers on the Mediabistro Job Board. Every job post comes with our satisfaction guarantee. Learn More
 

Our Sponsors

Mediabistro A division of Prometheus Global Media home | site map | advertising/sponsorships | careers | contact us | help courses | browse jobs | freelancers | content | member benefits | reprints & permissions terms of use | privacy policy Copyright © 2014 Mediabistro Inc. call (212) 389-2000 or email us